Admissions Blog

Undergraduate Admissions Uncensored

  • admissions.blog

The Most Essential College Admission

Posted on March 15, 2018 by Patrick O'Connor

He was on his way home from just having dropped all his classes at the local community college.  Having graduated from high school sixteen months ago, every one of his postsecondary plans had failed to come to fruition, and the drive home from campus gave him time to ponder what would come next.

As it turns out, he didn’t have to ponder long.  He came across a home construction site on the route home, and had always had an interest working with his hands.  He swung his car up to the site, got out, and asked the first hard-hatted worker just what it might take to get a job like this.  The worker turned out to be the contractor, who said that anyone who had the guts to pull up and ask was worth taking a chance on.  Find yourself a good pair of boots, he was told, and come back tomorrow.

That was the beginning of a postsecondary plan that stuck.  At age nineteen, he took on a job that paid $42,000, less than the median household income for his state, but far more than he would have earned working at the local sandwich shop.  His brief stint at community college left him little debt to be concerned with, and while his short-term plans doubtlessly included continued residency with his parents, it wouldn’t be long before he could afford an apartment of his own—and after that, his own home.

This is a remarkable story for several reasons, but what’s most noteworthy is the response this story receives from the school counselors and college admissions officers who hear it.  To nearly a person, they are convinced this young man has thrown away his future.  Citing countless personal and professional histories, they speak with clear certainty that he will regret his choice by the time he’s twenty-eight, only to find himself saddled with a mortgage or the well-being of a young family, unable to go back to college on a full-time basis, and therefore destined to be trapped in a job that appeared to pay well in his youth, but will limit his opportunities later in life.

This story comes to mind as we are weeks away from headlines that decry a different kind of postsecondary story:  the headlines of another round of record applicants to a handful of the most selective colleges in America, where statistics suggest admission is less likely than being struck by lightning.  Every seat in these colleges will be filled this fall by a promising, eager student, but the headlines turn their attention to the vast majority of exceptionally bright students who also had the potential to do great things at these colleges—except the college ran out of room before they ran out of quality applicants.

The way most stories tell it, these hapless applicants are victims of the postsecondary wheel of fortune, destined to try and make do at a college that likely is still highly regarded, but not quite as highly regarded, forced to devote part of their lives to perpetually looking back, and wondering what would have been if they had been one of the fortunate few whose cell phone had played the school’s fight song when they opened their emailed admissions decision.

Much has been written about the need for reform in America’s higher education system, and while there is ample agreement that the current system has need of correction, there is no clear consensus what that correction should look like.  Not surprisingly, testing companies insist the answer is more testing at an earlier age, while advocates of test-less admissions policies are convinced their approach is the only one that will open the gates of higher learning to a wider audience.  Others advocate for stackable college credentials that measure a semester’s worth of work as the only way to make college affordable, while developmental purists fret this approach would reduce the developmental benefits young people receive in the delayed gratification that is part of the four-year college experience.

These arguments make for interesting intellectual exercises, but they do little to help the students who had to “settle” for studying at the honors college of a four-year public university, or the students whose knowledge of geometry put college out of reach, but made them experts at framing walls and cutting pipe.  Our current system of higher education has many challenges, but the biggest one lies in changing the perception that there can only be a handful of winners once high school is over.  Different talents and different needs require different plans, and honoring those differences doesn’t require us to sacrifice the quality of the unum, simply because we honor the talents of the pluribus.

Our country is supposed to be a tent of opportunity.  Let’s advance that idea by seeing all our high school graduates as residents of the big top.

About Patrick O'Connor

Patrick O'Connor, Ph.D. has been a college counselor since 1984, serving students in rural, urban, and suburban high schools, as well as community college. He is the author of five books on college counseling, including the highly acclaimed College Counseling for School Counselors and the College is Yours series.

Filed Under: Advice & Analysis, Community Colleges, High School, Ivy League Tagged With: alternatives to college, career-technical education, college admissions, Intel

Related posts:

College Counseling: The Year in Review Thoughts and Prayers Aren’t Enough in College Admissions Either The Advantages of Open Admission Making a Calm College Decision

Subscribe to our mailing list

Best Summer Programs in Europe for High School Students

College Application Completion Playlist: Top 20+ Tracks to Get Inspiration to Get Into College

Making the most of the summer before senior year

You CAN apply Restrictive Early Action and Early Action under the right conditions

How to Get Accepted to Your Dream College of Choice

12 Reasons Scattergrams Lull Students Into a False Sense of Security

30 Summer STEM Camps for High School Freshmen

UNC and a tale of one – make that four – acceptance rates

Trending Posts

Another Reason Why Your Common Application Essay is So Bad

Avoid Tuition Anxiety: Put Strong Merit Aid Colleges on Your List

University of Washington Releases Admissions Decisions

University of Illinois Urbana-Champaign’s Impressive Acceptance Rate Transparency

Common Application Essay Prompts for 2023-2024 Confirmed

USC First-Year Applications Up 17%

Tulane’s acceptance rate is 13%. Only 34% are male.

Boston University’s Overall Acceptance Rate Drops to 10.7%

Write for Us | Sponsored Posts
All content © 2022 | Admissions.Blog
Terms of Service | +1 410-526-2558

Search Posts By Topic

  • 3 Year Degree (2)
  • Accommodations (2)
  • Admissions Policies (82)
  • Admissions Statistics (69)
  • Advice & Analysis (310)
  • Alabama (1)
  • Amherst (2)
  • AP (4)
  • Applications (62)
  • Arizona (4)
  • ASU (1)
  • Austin College (1)
  • Baylor (1)
  • Berry College (1)
  • Boston University (3)
  • Brown (3)
  • Bryn Mawr (1)
  • BYU (1)
  • Caltech (1)
  • Canada (2)
  • Career and Technical Education (7)
  • Case Western (3)
  • China (1)
  • CMC (1)
  • Coalition (13)
  • Colby (1)
  • College Counselor (18)
  • College Fairs (5)
  • College Life (31)
  • College List (33)
  • College List Deathmatch (4)
  • College Visit (22)
  • Columbia (5)
  • Common Application (35)
  • Community Colleges (4)
  • Cornell (3)
  • COVID-19 (8)
  • CSU (1)
  • CU Boulder (1)
  • Dartmouth (3)
  • Davidson (1)
  • Demonstrated Interest (17)
  • DePaul (1)
  • Dickinson (1)
  • Direct Admissions (1)
  • Duke (2)
  • Early Action (34)
  • Early Decision (37)
  • Enrichment (13)
  • Environmental Science (1)
  • Essays (27)
  • Europe (6)
  • Exercise Science (1)
  • Exeter (1)
  • Extracurricular Activities (24)
  • Feature (2)
  • Financial Aid (22)
  • First Person (9)
  • France (1)
  • FSU (1)
  • Gap Programs (2)
  • GED (1)
  • Georgetown (4)
  • Germany (2)
  • Gifts (3)
  • GPA (4)
  • Hamilton (1)
  • Harvard (6)
  • High School (21)
  • Higher National Diplomas (1)
  • HiSET (1)
  • IB (4)
  • IEC (1)
  • IELTS (1)
  • Indiana (3)
  • International (6)
  • Internships (5)
  • Interviews (10)
  • Iowa (1)
  • Italy (2)
  • Ivy League (19)
  • JHU (2)
  • LD (1)
  • Majors (11)
  • MIT (4)
  • Naviance (2)
  • NCAA (3)
  • New Mexico State University (1)
  • News (59)
  • Northwestern (3)
  • Notification News (2)
  • Notre Dame (3)
  • NYU (1)
  • Of Note (5)
  • Ohio State (1)
  • Open Admission (2)
  • Parents (7)
  • Penn (6)
  • Pitt (2)
  • Popular Posts (16)
  • Princeton (4)
  • Priority (2)
  • Professor of the Month (1)
  • PSU (3)
  • Public Universities (8)
  • Purdue (1)
  • Rankings (8)
  • Reader Questions (10)
  • Recommendations (8)
  • Regular (20)
  • Research (4)
  • Resume (16)
  • Rice (3)
  • ROI (2)
  • Rolling (5)
  • Santa Clara University (1)
  • Sewanee (1)
  • SMU (1)
  • South America (2)
  • Southwestern (TX) (1)
  • Spotlight Series (1)
  • St. Edward's University (1)
  • St. John's College (1)
  • Standardized Tests (30)
  • Stanford (3)
  • Summer (17)
  • Swarthmore (1)
  • TASC (1)
  • Teacher Recommendations (8)
  • Temple (1)
  • Texas (3)
  • Texas A&M (1)
  • Ticker (21)
  • Trending Posts (27)
  • Trinity University (TX) (1)
  • Tufts (3)
  • Tuition (3)
  • Tulane (5)
  • UC Berkeley (6)
  • UC Davis (1)
  • UC Santa Barbara (1)
  • UCAS (4)
  • UCLA (7)
  • UDub (1)
  • UF (2)
  • UGA (3)
  • UIUC (3)
  • UMass (1)
  • UMD (4)
  • UNC (1)
  • United Kingdom (6)
  • Universal College Application (1)
  • University of Chicago (1)
  • University of Dallas (1)
  • University of New Mexico (1)
  • University of Rochester (1)
  • USC (2)
  • UT Austin (1)
  • UVA (6)
  • Vanderbilt (1)
  • Video Game Design (1)
  • Villanova (2)
  • Wash U (5)
  • Williams (1)
  • Wisconsin (1)
  • Yale (10)
  • ZeeMee (1)

Copyright © 2023 · Metro Pro Theme on Genesis Framework · WordPress · Log in